Wilson writes in 1820:

The top Lady at A and bottom Gentleman at B advance, meet at F, Courtesy and Bow to each other, and then retire to places at A D; then the Lady at C and top Gentleman at B do the same: the top Lady and bottom Gentleman advance to the same Situation and swing with right Hands; the top Gentleman and bottom Lady do the same: then the top Lady and bottom Gentleman swing with left Hands; the top Gentleman and bottom Lady do the same: the top Gentleman and bottom Lady meet and turn with both Hands; the top Gentleman and bottom Lady do the same: then the top Lady and bottom Gentleman meet and Allemande round each other; the top Gentleman and bottom Lady do the same.

The top Couple at A B, bass each other at E, and cross over every Couple till they come to the Bottom, the Lady moving in Direction C D, and the Gentleman in the Line little c and d.* (Should the set be very long, they may cross over every other Couple, missing a Couple ever time; in crossing, the Lady passes in front of the Gentleman, that is, always passing the Gentleman on her Right Hand.)

The top Couple, by crossing over, will now be at the Bottom; they Cross Hands and Promenade up the middle, in the Lines c d; all the Couples follow them, beginning from the Bottom: the Ladies all follow the Lady that commenced the Dance in Line G; and the Gentlemen follow her Partner in the Direction H, by which means they all regain their Situations, except the Couple that begun the Dance, who will now be at the Bottom of the Room.

N.B. This Dance may be performed by any Number of Persons.

In A Pocket Companion, for Young Ladies and Gentlemen..., Smyth, 1830 calls the dance The Haymakers and writes:

The top Lady and bottom Gentleman advance to the middle, and turn by the right hand: the first Gentleman and last Lady do the same. The same couple repeat the same with the left hand, These again repeat the same by both hands. The first two advance and pass back to back, and return to their places. The other two do the same. The first Lady and bottom Gentleman advance, bow and curtsey, and return to their places; the others do the same. The whole chassé from top to bottom. the first couple half pousette with each couple till they reach the bottom of the Dance.

In Ball-Room Guide: A Manual of Dancing, H. D. Willock, 1868 calls the dance Sir Roger de Coverly, or The Haymakers and writes:

1. The first lady and last gentleman turn by the right hand, then by left hand, then by both hands, the back to back, then bow and courtesy. The above movements are repeated alternately by the partners of the leading couples . . . 40
2. Ladies cast off to right, gentlemen to left, meet at bottom; the first couple join hands, forming an arch, the others pass under to places . . . 8

The last part may be done thus:—
Ladies cast off to right, gentlemen to left, meet at bottom, and lead up,
First couple pousette to bottom.

In Kate Hughes's manuscript from Dundalk Ireland, 1867 it is also called "Hay Makers".

The couples stand in fours across the room, all facing the top, except the first two couples, who face down. Women on the right of their partners (See Fig.)

MUSIC	DESCRIPTION
Bars.
1-4	Couples 1 and 4 dance four hands across with right hands.
5-8	And back again with left hands.
9-12	Couples 2 and 3 dance four hands across with right hands.
13-16	And back again with left hands.
17-24	All four couples set twice and turn partners with both hands.
25-28	All four couples, partners facing each other and joining both hands, slip across to one another's places, men passing back to back.
29-32	Slip across back to places, women passing back to back.
33-36	{ First and third couples dance four hands round to the left. Second and fourth couples dance four hands round to the left.
37-40	The same couples giving left hands, dance four hands across back to places.
41-43	All four couples advance (two steps) and retire (one step).
44	Give three claps with the hands.
45-48	Couples 1 and 2 dancing down the dance, pass under the arms of couples 3 and 4, who are dancing up.
	Repeat, with next two couples, and do the same figures with every line until they arrive at the bottom of the dance. As each line reaches top or bottom of the set, change to correct side of partners and stand during one turn of the dance.
	NOTE.— This dance can also be done in groups of four in a circle in which case bars 9-16 are omitted.

Collected locally.

(I believe this to be the original text as printed in 1925, subsequent revisions of the book use different words but describe the same figure.)

If you look at the Scottish Country Dance Database and Dictionary they both claim the four face four version of the dance should be done round the room as well, but the book shows a longways dance with four lines of two couples each, not a round the room dance. In his The Modern Dancing Master, Chivers, London, 1822 describes dancing four face four dances round the room. He calls this a Chivonian Circle.

The (R)SCDS did not say how many times the dance should be repeated. For a four line dance the traditional number would be nine repetitions leaving everyone where they started, but the SCDS is more likely to follow their own methods and only repeat the dance 8 times (leaving the bottom two lines in the wrong places).

In it's 2008 revision of Book 2, the RSCDS attributes this dance to Lowe's Selection of Popular Country Dances, ~1850. Lowe actually publishes two different figures, one which he teaches and which he claims to be the original version, and one which everyone else in Edinburgh dances. Lowe's "Original" version is unlike any other version I've found (nobody else has the dancers clapping, ever), while the other version seems more like the other contemporary versions I've found. The (R)SCDS chose Lowe's "Original" as the basis for their dance.

Lowe writes:

ANY number of couples can join in this Dance, arranging themselves four and four across the room, and all facing the top except the first couple, who face the other way, the Ladies standing on the right of their partners, thus-

1st Couple,	L. G. L. G. 0 + 0 +
2nd Couple,	G. L. G. L. + 0 + 0
3rd Couple,	G. L. G. L. + 0 + 0

Each line as they arrive at the top, face about to be ready to commence.

---

Original Figure, as danced by Mr. Lowe's Pupils.

The couples on the right of each line, at angular corners, do hands across and back again to places (8 bar); the couples on the left of each line do the same (8 bars); all eight set and turn partners (8 bars); all eight gallopade across each other, the couples on the right of each line passing in front (4 bars) back again, the other couple passing in front (4 bars). The couples opposite to each other go hands four round (4 bars), all giving left hands, do hands across back again (4 bars); all eight advance and retire, and give three claps with the hands (4 bars); then the couples dancing down the dance pass under the arms of those dancing up (4 bars); then commence the figure with the next couples; then do the same figure with every line till they arrive at the end of the dance, then face about and dance up again.

Courtesy of National Library of Scotland, licensed under:

I think Lowe wants the top couples to pass under the arches made by the bottom as couples, rather than passing by the right, as is the modern method. Lowe also has people do a couples mad robin along their own line, rather than a couples do-si-do with the people opposite.

Joseph Lowe did not suggest dancing it as a round the room dance. The earliest source I have for that is in Albert W. Newman's A Complete Practical Guide to Modern Society Dancing, Philadelphia, 1903 who wrote:

NOTE. — This waiting, however, can be avoided by placing the couples in a complete circle. It is then advisable to arrange but two couples in each set facing each other.

`,

He, like the (R)SCDS, only recommends the round the room format when the set is a standard improper duple minor rather than a four face four.

Despite the RSCDS's claims, this dance, and the idea of dancing in a four face four (Mescolanze) formation, predate Mr. Lowe.

The earliest version I have found was published by Kattfuß in Germany in 1802.

According to The Regency Dance site Joseph Binns Hart published "Hart's 2nd Set of Quadrilles" sometime between 1818 and 1820. In this work he has a dance called Hart's Tempete Dance which was a dance with two couples facing two other couples (a rare formation for cotillions, but not unknown), however unlike cotilions (or quadrilles) Hart's dance progresses.

In his Hart's Second Set of Quadrilles, Hart writes:

Form a line of 4, the 2 Ladies on the 2 Gentlemens right, 4 more opposite to the first 4, form lines of 4 behind the 2^d. line as many as intend to dance.

---

FIGURE

The first 2 lines right and left, chassez across to the right and left with your partner, dechassez, in returning you go behind the 2^d. Couple The Center 4 hands round, the outside couple's turn and back all 8 Set quite round to the right re set to your places, the top four lead through the 2^d. line and begin the same figure with the 3^d. line & so on to the bottom of the dance.

Then in ~1825 GMS Chivers published a dance called La Tempête in his "Dancing Master in Miniature".

The Contrafusion site says the dance was originally European and dates it back to 1802.

In the US, the earliest source I can lay my hands on is from New York in the US in 1851, which was a mescolanze (but not a round the room dance) Mr. Whale & Daughter published La Tempète, as danced at the Queen's Last Ball

This popular Dance is danced by any number of double couples standing as above at commencement. All begin together, — Advance and retire twice, — Partners together gallop across eight steps each way, — Advance and retire twice, — Hand four round in the centre, (as above) Sides the same turning with both hands, — Hands across, (as above) Sides the same, — Advance and retire once, — Go forward to dance with next vis a vis.

Also in 1851, also in New York, Burnton published The Original Tampete

This popular dance is dance by any number of double couples, standing as above at commencement, all begin at once.

1. All forward and back, (4 bars) half right and left, (4 bars) forward and back, (4 bars) half right and left to place (4 bars)
2. Couples Galop eight steps to the left, (4 bars) then eight steps to the right, (4 bars)
3. Small stars (Each double couple form a star, Ladies cross hands, Gents also, round eight steps to the left (4 bars) change eight steps to the right (4 bars)
4. Grand star (Four couples. Ladies take Gents arms & cross hands in centre, eight steps round to the left, (4 bars) change Gentlemen swing in centre and cross hands, Ladies remain on Gents arms outside. eight steps round to the right. (4 bars)
5. Circles (Each double couple form a circle, hands round, eight steps to the left, (4 bars) eight steps to the right (4 bars)

All advance first couple holding hands up, others passing quick through and advance to the new couples. This forms the first figure again, and must therefore be no time lost, when passing through to the next.

These are the original and true figures, as danced in Europe

I have a page devoted to a more complete history of this dance.

The RSCDS attributes this to Mozart Allan's Allan's Reference Guide to the Ball-Room, Glasgow, ~1895, and a dance with this name and figure is in that work, but it occurred elsewhere earlier.

Published by Goulding & D'Almaine in 1827 as Blue Bonnets are over the Border. I do not have access to the original text. but Robert Keller gives the figures as:
Change sides
Change sides (again)
Lead down and back
Poussette

Smyth, in 1830, page 31, calls it Blue Bonnets Over the Border and writes:

First Lady and second Genlemen advance and retire, and pass back to back, the first Gentleman and second Lady the same Down the middle and up again, and poussette.

So where is the progression in this dance? Either in the poussette or in "down the middle and up again". If you look at Mrs McLeod (page 33) you will see that, for Smyth, "down the middle and up again" is progressive.

Smyth (an Edinburgh dancing teacher) classifies this as a "Scotch Country Dance".

This dance was probably danced for about a hundred years before anyone bothered to publish it. The earliest Scottish source I can find is Smyth in 1830 who writes:

At the commencement, the Gentlemen place their partners at the end of the room, and stand either before or beside them.— If before them, all four begin at once, but if otherwise the Ladies must begin first, each person describing the figure eight, and the Gentlemen set to the Ladies alternately.

The Lowes in ~1831 write:

Before commencing the Reel of Four, the Gentlemen place their partners upon opposite sides of the room, or at the ends, and stand either before or beside them; if before them, all the four must begin at once; but if otherwise, the Ladies ought to begin first; each person describes the figure of eight, and the Gentlemen set to the Ladies alternately.

Arthur Miller, Leeds, 1900 writes:

In commencing the Reel of Four, the gentlemen stand back to back, with their partners opposite them, all commence at the one time. Each person describes the figure 8. The gentlemen pass the ladies on the right hand; gentlemen pass each other in the centre, pass on the left; the ladies always return to their first places, gentlemen change places every time with each other, eight bars.

All set to each other, eight bars.

Unfortunately this description is misleading. The figure of a reel for four people is not a figure eight, it's a figure eight with an extra loop. The Fletts kindly point this out.

The Fletts also mention that the reel should be performed "giving shoulders", that is when passing someone of the opposite sex in the reel the shoulder closest to that person should lead (so the dancers are almost back to back), while when passing someone of the same sex the outside shoulder should lead (so the dancers are almost face to face). The RSCDS says nothing of this, but doesn't say not to do it either...

Although the glory of the dance is in the various setting steps used, the arms were also involved. The Fletts say that the most common position was for the dancers to hold their arms akimbo. Though the gentlemen often raised their arms (one, or both, or alternating), and the ladies sometimes raised theirs, and sometimes used them to hold their skirts out.

The earliest written description of the dance actually comes from Thomas Wilson's Analysis of Country Dancing, London, 1808 (page 120). His version is rather different. It starts with two facing couples, each couple turns (I presume a two hand turn), and then everyone turns their opposite, that repeats (turn partner, turn opposite), then the 1st couple crosses in between the second and hey with them. On the second iteration the 2nd couple cross to hey with the 1st.

The RSCDS attributes this to the 9th edition to the Dancing Master.

This dance has a rather confusing history in the Dancing Master. In 1651 (the first edition) Playford called essentially the same tune "Stingo, or The Oyl of Barly". This dance had a completely different figure though.

Then in 1689 addition to the 7th edition he published two dances with different figures but the same tune: "Juice of Barley" and "Cold and Raw". In the 9th edition (1695) the dance originally titled "Juice of Barley" became "Cold and Raw". The original "Cold and Raw" disappeared from the 9th through the 16th editions, and then reappeared as "Cold and Raw" in the 17th edition (1721) while the "Juice of Barley" figure then vanished.

The RSCDS version appears to be based on the "Juice of Barley" figure.

Playford writes:

The 1. cu. go back to back with their Partners, and the 2. cu. do the same at the same time.

---

The 1. cu. take hands with his Partner and turn her round, the 2. cu. doing the same at the same time.

---

The two we. stand still whilst the 1. man goes round about the 2. wo. into the 2. man's place, and the 2. man goes round about the 1. wo. into the 1. man's place, then all clap hands, then all four take hands and go quite round, the we. doing the like.

Although Playford explicitly specifies a two hand turn, the RSCDS has chosen to do a right hand turn.

Quoted from The Register of Dances at Castle Menzies (as transcribed by Jim Healy):

1^st man turns 2^d woman & casts off, then the 1^st woman does the same then the 1^st pair goes figure of eight through the 2^d pair; then the 1^st man sets to the 2^d woman & turns her, then the 1^st woman the same; then the 1^st pair goes four hands round with the 2^d pair & right & left

Walsh writes:

The 1st Man Heys with the 3d Cu. his Partner at the same Time heys with the 2d Cu. Then the 1st Man Heys with the 2d Cu. 1st Wo. at the same Time Heys with the 3d Cu. First Cu. leads thro' the 2d and 3d We. and turn in the 2d Cu. Place First Cu. leads through the 2d and 3d Men and turns at Top The 1st Cu. Back to Back and cast off and turn The 2d Cu. does the same First Man leads the 2d Wo. off and turns her First Wo. leads the 2d Man off and turns him, 1st Man cast off at the same Time.

Walsh spells the dance "Soldier Ladie" rather than "Sodger Laddie".

Walsh uses a 32 bar jig tune repeated twice, while the RSCDS has cut the dance length in half.

RSCDS Book 12 attributes this to Johnson's Caledonian Country Dances of 1748 but it appears earlier.

According to Robert Keller's site Walsh published a dance called The Yellow Hair'd Laddie in his Caledonian Country Dances. Book the Second published ~1737.

Some years later Johnson published a dance with the same name and figure in his Caledonian Country Dances...ye 3d. Edition with Additions. A copy of this is online.

Johnson writes:

The 1^st. Cu. lead thro' the 2^d. Cu. & turn in their own Places, then Back to Back and turn The 2^d. Cu. do the same with the 3^d. Cu. Then the 1^st Cu. cast behind the 3^d. Cu. and lead up to the Top and turn then Back to Back and Right Hand & Left to the end of the Tune —

The music consists of 2 eight bar strains, both repeated.

What to make of The 1^st. Cu. lead thro' the 2^d. Cu. & turn in their own Places? What are "their own Places"? Sometimes that means their original places, and sometimes it means their progressed places. The RSCDS thinks it means their progressed places (which means the 2s must move up), but the next instruction The 2^d. Cu. do the same with the 3^d. Cu. suggests that the 2s and 3s are adjacent, which won't happen if the 2s have moved up. RSCDS seems to assume that's a misprint, and that Walsh means "1s" instead of "3s".

But if we assume Walsh meant what he wrote we still get a consistent dance. I think The 1^st. Cu. lead thro' the 2^d. Cu. is probably an abreviation for "1s lead down and cast back to place". We've got 4 bars of music at 3 counts a bar, and even at minuet pacing that's a lot of music just to lead down one couple, but it's about right to lead down and cast up. Then the 1s can do their turns and back-to-back "in their own Places" at the top of the set. And then the 2s can do the same with the 3s.

In the second half of the dance Walsh says Then the 1^st Cu. cast behind the 3^d. Cu. and lead up, but the RSCDS has them casting down 1 couple and leading up, not the 2 couple cast Walsh asks for

Some sources say the turns in the first 32 bars should be right hand, and some say both hand.

The crib diagram shows the "down the middle" to be with near hands joined but the online instructions say "lead".

The RSCDS attributes this dance to David Rutherford, but John Johnson published the same figure a few years earlier. He and Rutherford used the same words, and Rutherford is online. Rutherford writes:

The first Man sets to the 2^d. Wo. & turn her His Partner does the same with the 2^d. Man Cross over 2 Cu. Lead up to the Top foot it & cast off · Back to Back with your Partner Right Hand and Left Quite round with the 2^d. Couple ··

The instructions as printed by Rutherford do not work, they end with the 1s improper.

To avoid this I have changed the cast off at the end of B1 to a cross and cast.

The threes are idle. And the "cross 2 couple, lead to top" seems too much to fit in four bars. The dance cries out to be a duple minor (as is done in the Scottish interpretation).

A dance with this name was published by Button & Whittaker, but whether it matches the figure I do not know. The RSCDS attributes this dance to the publishers but Wilson was the deviser: see the Regency Dance site's paper on Button and Co. The use of double triangles does suggest Wilson was the choreographer.

Thompson writes:

Set to your partner and turn foot it sides and turn Hands round Back to Back all 4 Gallop down one Cu: up again and cast off

The RSCDS gives no source to this dance, but it appears to be derived from Nathaniel Kynaston's Mrs. Hill's Dance published by both Walsh and Playford in 1710.

Note: Each Strain is to be play'd twice over.

The first Cu. slip down the middle, and Sett a-cross to the third Cu. then first Man turn the third Wo. and the first Wo. turn the third Man Then Sett a-cross to the 2d Cu. then first Man turn the 2d Man half round, and the first Wo. turn the 2d Wo. at the same Time Then Right-hand and Left round, then turn Partners Proper Then the Man slips between the 2d Cu. and cast off, the first Wo. at the same Time go between the third Cu. and cast up, then both turn in the 2d Couple's Place

Note: Each Strain is to be play'd twice over.

The first Couple cast off and fall in between the second and third Woman and Man, and lead backward and forward Then first Woman cast off and fall in between the third Man and third Woman, the Man cast up and fall in between the second Man and second Women at the same Time; then lead backward and forward The first Man and first Woman meet and fall back, the Man cast off round the second Woman, and the second Woman cast up round the third Man, then Righ and Lift quite round Back to Back with your own, then Back with the second Couple, then the Man lead his Partner up round the second Woman into their proper Places, Sett and cast off

The Tweed is a river on the border between Scotland and England, flowing into the North Sea.

The original is a 24 bar dance with 3 counts per bar; it has been adapted to a 48 bar jig.

Kynaston writes:

Each Strain twice.

The 1^st. and 2^d. man go back to back with their partners, and turn each a whole round and a half then back to back sides and turn as before men being improper, the 1^st. cu. go right hands and left with the 2^d. cu. half round, all dance and turn single the 1^st. cu. lead through the 3^d. cu. cast up and turn partners quite round

SINGLE FIGURE (Each strain repeated)
Hands 3 round on the ladies side hands 3 round on the gent^ns. side   lead down the middle up again & allemande  

OR THUS Set & change places with 2^d. Cu: set & back again   & whole poussette  

DOUBLE FIGURE (Tune played twice thro' with repeats)
Set & hands across quite round with 2^d. Cu: set & back again   lead down the middle up again set to top Cu:   swing corners   chain figure four round with top Cu: & turn your partner  

The music consists of two 4 bar strains. Probably played as a reel rather than a strathspey.

The RSCDS is interpretting Wilson's DOUBLE FIGURE

Wilson defines most of his figures in his An Analysis of Country Dancing, 3rd Edition.

1. Set & hands across quite round is one figure which Wilson does not define. However he defines hands across on page 12 where he defines a normal hands across but says they only turn half round (with a footnote saying it is often done by turning completely round and then back again).
   So I'm going to assume that quite round actually means half round. So two bars of setting, followed by two bars to do half a hands across.
2. lead down the middle up again set to the top Cu: may be found on page 8 Top couple leads down to between the third couple, 1s turn and lead up to 2nd place as the second couple move up (Wilson's pictures show them moving up the sidelines and not leading), then actives set (or foot it) to the second couple. (This seems to take 8 bars)
3. swing corners is defined on pages 55-58 and appears to mean: the 1s turn partner by the right hand then 1st corners by the left hand, partner right, 2nd corners left and returning home the shortest way (by the left shoulder).
4. Chain figure for four may be found on page 76 and boils down to what anyone else would call rights and lefts.
5. Turn your partner may be found on page 2 and boils a two hand turn (Wilson calls a right hand turn "swing your partner").

Playford's music is a slip-jig consisting of two 4 bar strains, both repeated.

Playford writes:

First man take the 2. man by the right hand, and turn a turn and a half, the 1 and 2 wo. do the same at the same time till they come into the 2. cu. place, back to back with your own, then turn your own, and back to back, sides-men go without-side the we. and come between them a quarter Figure, turn S. we. do the like

---

Note: Each Strain is to be play'd twice over.

Interesting the the RSCDS is unwilling to use a turn single...

I have not yet found a copy of Anderson's earlier work but this dance also appears in D. Anderson's Ball-Room and Solo Dance Guide, of 1897, wherein he writes:

Reel Time.

Top couple down the centre and back.

Top lady turn second gent. by right arm half a measure, then turn by left arm half a measure.

At the same time top gent. turns second lady by right arm half a measure, then turn by left arm half a measure.

Reel four across the dance.

Pousette with own partners.

Repeat figure to bottom.

Courtesy of National Library of Scotland, licensed under:

On page 117 Anderson claims to be the devisor of this dance.

SINGLE FIGURE (Each strain repeat)
Set & change sides with 2^d. Cu: set & back again   swing with right hands round 2^d. Cu: & allemande  

OR THUS The 1^st lady meets & turns the 2^d gent: the 1^st. gent: meets and turns the 2^d lady   lead down the middle up again & set to the top Cu:  

DOUBLE FIGURE (Tune played twice thro' with repeats)
Hands 6 round & back   promenade 3 Cu:   whole poussette   & the double triangle  

Wilson spells the title as "The Carle came o'er the Craft".

The music consists of two 4 bar strains.

The RSCDS is interpretting Wilson's DOUBLE FIGURE (The Wilson's poussette and double triangle are completely different from those of the RSCDS).

Wilson defines most of his figures in his An Analysis of Country Dancing, 3rd Edition.

1. hands 6 round & back again may be found on page 5 and means what you expect. All take hands and circle left then right.
2. promenade 3 Cu: is defined on page 18 and means that all three couples take promenade hold and, with the 1s leading, travel in a counter-clockwise elipse around and back to places.
3. whole poussette is defined on page 15 and means: "top two couples join hands with partner, circle, counter-clockwise, one and a half times around the other couple to change places with them."
   Note: this is unlike a normal English Poussette as the couples travel once and a half around each other rather than once. And is quite different from the Scottish Poussette.
4. the double triangle is defined on page 113 and means: "the middle couple loop first corner right shoulder pass outside partner's place, then loop 2nd corner right shoulder and return to place.
   This is completely different from the RSCDS version of double triangles.